OK, I just finished reading the final six debut issues of the New 52. Reading them all has been fun, but it's a lot of comics. I don't know when I last read this many comics in one month, but it's been a long while.
The Savage Hawkman #1 is confusing for me because I don't understand the idea of the Nth Metal. I thought Hawkman was from Hawkworld, but I guess it's all been changed. This issue begins with Carter Hall trying to rid himself of the Nth Metal and any connection to Hawkman. He fails, of course, and goes missing while some of his colleagues dredge up a mystery object from the ocean floor. It eventually unleashes all kinds of nasty and Carter finds himself morphing back into Hawkman to fight it. As you can tell, the story, by Tony Daniel, is pretty average. What I really liked was the art by Philip Tan and the coloring by Sunny Gho. This is a nice looking book — it has a painted look, though close inspection reveals that to not be the case. I don't have an emotional connection to Hawkman, so I doubt I'll be back, but this is a decent comic.
After getting a lot of criticism last week for the portrayal of women in the New 52, we next come to Voodoo #1. Another Wildstorm refugee, this one sees the former member of Jim Lee's WildC.A.T.S. working as a stripper while being investigated for some reason by a couple of agents. Turns out, she's an alien with telepathy who finds it easy to learn about men as a stripper because they're guards are down while they watch her. It's not much of an explanation, but it is one. The end also indicates that the stripper locale is a one-issue affair, and the plot will move on into some more interesting areas. The art by Sami Basri is, as you'd expect for a story set in a strip club, replete with women wearing skimpy clothes and in various levels of undress. The biggest problem with this issue is it doesn't deliver enough of anything — mystery, character, suspense, plot — to make me want to stick around. It's just thin, and hangs on a reveal that anyone familiar with the character had already figured out.
Justice League Dark #1 is a silly book that tries to jam together characters unsuited to a superhero into a superhero team. This should be called Justice League Vertigo, as it features Madame Xanadu, John Constantine and Shade: The Changing Man, as well as Deadman and Zatanna. Like Justice League International, there's not much of a connection here to the main Justice League title save a short appearance by Batman. The story is pretty standard "assemble the team" stuff, but it hurts just a little bit to see characters like Constantine be forced into a costume story when they're just not made for it.
Batman: The Dark Knight #1 has some really pretty artwork from David Finch, but otherwise feels completely superfluous. Batman and Detective Comics still feel like the "real" books, and this and Batman and Robin are spinoffs that will come and go while the others remain the center of the Bat-verse. This is still a decent Batman comic, but it's the kind that's aimed at the die-hard fan and completist. On a side note, there's one really odd, prominent panel of a female Arkham inmate wearing a skimpy outfit that includes a thong with a bunny tail on it. I'll wait to see what the reaction is to that.
I, Vampire #1 managed to overcome my longstanding dislike of vampires and I really enjoyed it. This may be the breakout original title of the New 52 — I really hope it is. It's deftly written by Joshua Hale Fialkov and sports some really incredible artwork from Andrea Sorrentino. I don't think any description of the plot will do it justice, just go read it — even if you can't stand vampires.
And the final first issue of the New 52 is Teen Titans #1, from Red Hood and the Outlaws scribe Scott Lobdell and veteran artists Brett Booth and Norm Rapmund. Thankfully, this was a lot more like Lobdell's script for Superboy than for Red Hood. It starts with the mistake-ridden, overconfident debut of Kid Flash, followed by Tim Drake — who has kept the Red Robin moniker — assembling a new team. It's got the same sort of snappy pace and dialoge that Lobdell is known for, and he makes it work quite well with these characters. I expect the ret-con of Wonder Girl will prompt some outcries. It appears her previous connection to Wonder Woman is gone and her powers are quite different. But she has a personality — perhaps still at this point a stock personality, but she still has one — as does Red Robin and the cocky new Kid Flash. I have long found Booth's figures to be a bit stiff, but this is a big improvement from his 1990s efforts with Wildstorm and the X-Men books at Marvel, so good for him. While I am not the biggest fan anymore of teen books, I still might give this shot based on the energy that this first issue delivers.
And with that, the pile of New 52 comics sitting on top of a longbox in my office is complete. I'd love to know what anyone else thinks of these books. Do you agree with my take, disagree, partially agree? Send me links, comments or emails if you're so inclined. I'll be taking a look at others' reviews and expect to post some kind of wrapup before the second issues hit starting next week.